| 2018 | Samantha Greene | James Billings | Emily Turnbull | Josh Rogerson | Brittany Bordignon |
| 2017 | Stevern Jeffery | Stephen Leitch | Emily Turnbull | Grant Dowler | Brenton Anderson |
| 2016 | Brett Tonkin | Stevern Jeffery | Samantha Greene | Lachlan Watson | Brenton Anderson |
| 2015 | Brett Tonkin | Sam Condon | Samantha Greene | Lachlan Watson | Jordan Prasad |
| 2014 | Brett Tonkin | Mark O’Brien | Samantha Greene | Imogen McKee | Jordan Prasad |
| 2013 | Brett Tonkin | Michael Harney | Samantha Greene | Imogen McKee | Ross Slater |
| 2012 | David McMaster | Luke Heathcote | Not Elected | Imogen McKee | Ross Slater |
| 2011 | David McMaster | Brad Van Ooi | Jess Smith | Brett Muir | Luke Heathcote |
| 2010 | Brad Van Ooi | John Dumaresq | - | David McMaster | Alex Knight |
| 2009 | Brad Van Ooi | John Dumaresq/Ron Adams | - | David McMaster | Stephen Pruscino |
| 2008 | John Dumaresq | Ron Adams | - | Brad Van Ooi | Stephen Pruscino |
| 2007 | John Dumaresq | John Williamson | - | Brad Van Ooi | Stephen Pruscino |
| 2006 | John Dumaresq | Luke Heathcote | - | Ross Slater | Stephen Pruscino |
| 2005 | John Dumaresq | Luke McNamara | - | Ross Slater | Luke Heathcote |
| 2004 | John Dumaresq | Ron Adams | - | Luke McNamara | Luke Heathcote |
| 2003 | John Dumaresq | Ron Adams | - | Luke McNamara | Antony Murphy |
| 2002 | John Dumaresq | Ron Adams | - | Tim Peters | Kris Hopkins |
| 2001 | John Dumaresq | Ron Adams | - | Tim Peters/Brent Hewitt | Anthony Poulton/Luke Heathcote |
| 2000 | John Dumaresq | Michael Napier | - | Luke Heathcote | Philip Moon |
| 1999 | John Dumaresq | Luke Ryan | - | Luke Heathcote | Philip Moon |
| 1998 | John Dumaresq | David Sidebottom | - | Luke Heathcote | Stephen Longeran |
| 1997 | John Dumaresq | David Sidebottom | - | Jesse Maddison | Stephen Longeran |
| 1996 | Mick Brosnan | David Sidebottom | - | Luke McNamara | Scott Haynes |
| 1995 | Mick Brosnan | Jeremy Cousins | - | Luke McNamara | Scott Haynes |
| 1994 | Kevin McNicholl | Jeremy Cousins | - | John Mills | John Mills |
| 1993 | Jeremy Cousins | Kevin McNicholl | - | John Mills | David Hawking |
| 1992 | Shane Strong | Andrew Brennan/Jeremy Cousins | - | John Mills | David Hawking |
| 1991 | Kevin McNicholl | Peter O’Donohue/Shane Strong | - | John Mills | Bronwyn Wilson |
| 1990 | Kevin McNicholl | Alan Blaskett | - | Maree McNicholl | Bronwyn Wilson |
| 1989 | Kevin McNicholl | Andrew Huffer | - | Maree McNicholl | Andrew Huffer |
| 1988 | Kevin McNicholl | Peter Gough/John Mills | - | Peter O’Donohue | Peter Gough |
| 1987 | Barry Reichelt | Kevin McNicholl | - | Mary Reichelt | Kevin McNicholl |
| 1986 | Barry Reichelt | Peter Gough/Kevin McNicholl | - | Mary Reichelt | Peter Gough/Kevin McNicholl |
| 1985 | Barry Reichelt | Andrew Hannah | - | David Huffer | Andrew Hannah |
| 1984 | Peter Gannon | Barry Reichelt/Ken Peak | - | Carol Westley | Ken Peak |
| 1983 | Peter Gannon | Barry Reichelt/Greg Edwards | - | David Stephens | Ken Peak |
| 1982 | Peter Gannon | Barry Reichelt/Greg Edwards | - | David Stephens | Ken Peak |
| 1981 | Peter Gannon | John Graham | - | John Dawson/Andrew Heath | Ken Peak |
| 1980 | Craig Nelson | Owen Hughes | - | Bruce Prosser | Peter Gannon |
| 1979 | Jack Hoysted | Craig Nelson | - | Bruce Prosser | Peter Gannon |
| 1978 (La Trobe Blacks & La Trobe Reds amalgamate) | Jack Hoysted | Craig Nelson | - | Peter McGrath | Peter Gannon |
| 1977 | Russell Badham | John Graham/Craig Nelson | - | Brendan Kelly/John Ryan/Kevin McElwain | Mick Brewin |
| 1976 | Russell Badham | Russell Badham/Bernie Fox | - | John Wright/Brendan Kelly/John Ryan | Mick Brewin |
| 1975 | Tony Sheehan | Geoff Ryan/Russell Badham | - | John Wright/Brendan Kelly/Matthew Bennett | Mick Brewin |
| 1974 | Jim McMillan | Geoff Ryan/Tom Condon | - | John Wright/Gavin Drew | Darryl Salmon |
| 1973 | Bob Segrave | Jim McMillan | - | Robert Ziebell/Gavin Drew | Darryl Salmon |
| 1972 | Bob Segrave | Michael O’Connor/Jim McMillan | - | Darryl Salmon | Darryl Salmon |
| 1971 | Bob Segrave | Michael O’Connor/Phil McDonough | - | Jim McMillan | David Carland |
| 1970 | Bob Segrave | Michael O’Connor/Phil McDonough | - | John Pech | Graeme Anyon |
| 1969 | Bob Segrave | Michael O’Connor/Phil McDonough | - | Jim McMillan | Ivan Roberts |
| 1968 | Bob Segrave | Phil McDonough | - | Andrew Gee | Andrew Gee |
| 1967 | Bob Segrave | Phil McDonough | - | Andrew Gee | Andrew Gee |
